New York Loses Over 100,000 Apartments

By Ben Campbell · November 5, 2023 · 2 min read
Luxury condo tower, 432 Park Avenue, stands in Midtown Manhattan
Source: Spencer Platt/Getty Images

New York City is facing a severe housing crisis, leaving tens of thousands of citizens struggling to find a place to rent.

According to recent reports, over 50,000 family row houses have been remodeled into one or two-family homes, bringing forth a loss of 100,000 potential apartments.

New York Housing Problem

Residential buildings seen in the Brooklyn borough of NYC
Source: Spencer Platt/Getty Images

New York is famed for its towering buildings and apartment complexes overlooking the vast city.

However, a problem with the housing market has been occurring for some time, leading to the loss of over 100,000 potential homes.

The Loss of 100,000 Homes

View from the Chelsea apartments in the neighborhood of Manhattan
Source: Drew Angerer/Getty Images

One analysis from preservationist Adam Brodheim believes he has found the problem.

He claims that over the past 70 years, approximately 50,000 multi-family buildings have been converted into one or two-family homes, bringing about a loss of close to 100,000 units.

Bringing Attention to the Problem

Historic building stands in Manhattan’s SoHo neighborhood
Source: Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Brodeim said, "I'm not trying to begrudge folks who are trying to build a larger apartment as their families grow."

He continued, "I'm trying to bring attention to the way these actions across the entire city make a meaningful impact on our housing crisis."

Brodheim’s Report

Construction workers work on a construction site in NYC
Source: Michael M Santiago/Getty Images

Brodeim explained in his master's thesis that many row houses in the city once served as multi-family residences.

Yet, from 320,777 row houses in New York City, over 50,000 were converted to accommodate just one or two families.

New York’s Wealthiest Neighborhoods

Expensive house in the Manhattan borough of New York
Source: Scott Heins/Getty Images

Matthew Pietrus, an urban planner from the city, has also conducted similar research.

He claims apartments were disappearing at an alarming rate in New York’s wealthiest neighborhoods, including the West Village, Cobble Hill, and the Upper East Side.

Not Necessarily a Bad Thing

A new residential apartment building stands under construction in Brooklyn
Source: Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Apartment consolidation isn’t necessarily considered a bad thing, according to Brodheim.

If homeowners decide they want or need more space, they should have the option to create it if they can afford it.

Region-Wide Wide Housing Shortage

The sun sets on the under-construction headquarters for JPMorgan Chase
Source: Gary Hershorn/Getty Images

But, the loss of over 100,000 homes during a housing shortage concerns many people.

This is forcing many lower and middle-income people out of the city and making life in the Big Apple unaffordable for millions of others.

Not the Only Problem

Traditional tenement buildings on Orchard Street, New York City

According to the experts, there are a few other reasons why rent and home prices in New York have skyrocketed in recent years.

The most apparent is that New York’s rate of new housing construction has slowed down, fueling a citywide affordability crisis.

It Doesn’t Add Up

Home for rent in the Fort Greene area of New York City
Source: Drew Angerer/Getty Images

While the number of new jobs in New York City has increased by over 20% since 2010, the housing supply has only increased by around 4%.

Half of the people who live in New York City are rent-burdened, meaning they spend upwards of 30% of their income just on housing.

A Plan for Affordable Housing

People work in an office building in lower Manhattan
Source: Gary Hershorn/Getty Images

Plans are being set in place by developers to help the housing shortage by making use of the unused office space in the city.

As office spaces see a record vacancy rate amidst the remote-worker boom, Mayor Eric Adams is pushing for these empty buildings to be turned into apartments.

Mayor Adams’ Plan for NYC

Mayor Eric Adams speaks during a recent event in NYC
Source: Jonny Nunez/Getty Images

According to the mayor's plan, he would create over 100,000 new homes for 250,000 citizens of New York over the next 15 years.

While this won't solve all of the city’s housing problems, it's definitely a step in the right direction.