The Infamous Legacy of Doc Holliday and Other Western Outlaws

By: Mia Williams | Last updated: Feb 08, 2022

Back in the Wild West, some eccentric outlaws entered history books and onto the big screen, including the notorious bandit Butch Cassidy, who stole from banks and trains to give to the poor. Pretty Boy Floyd is another famous American outlaw known for aiding struggling farmers by robbing banks and fighting back against tyranny.

Others worked alone or with a gang, but none can compare to Doc Holliday — not because he was lawless, as so many outlaws are, or because he was possibly one of the greatest gunslingers of his time. Nor did he cause conflict in every town he visited. Some historians have commented that there’s more than what meets the eye with this infamous figure.

Born and Raised in the South

Born August 14, 1851, Doc Holliday lived in Griffin, Georgia, with his mother, one of the women he would later immortalize in “The Life of John Henry Holliday.” Impaired as a child by a cleft palate, he learned to speak much better after countless hours of coaching at the knee of his besotting momma.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons

No one could have guessed that he would enter legend lore with his well-known camaraderie alongside Wyatt Earp in the volatile events at the OK Corral.

Advertisement

A Western Genius

“Doc” Holliday was the beloved son of a pharmacist and a school teacher. Because he grew up watching his parents teach people about the wonders of western healing, he naturally developed a profound love for medicinal remedies and became fascinated by mathematics!

Advertisement

Photo by Underwood Archives/Getty Images

He probably spent many days being addressed as “mister literary scholar,” as he was known to be an avid reader, interested chiefly in science and medicine, as well as other novels.

Advertisement

Traineeship For Dentistry

Doc’s devoted mother fell ill with tuberculosis in 1866, when Doc was only 15 years old. Her death was brought on by the disease shortly after. Doc’s only means of coping with the devastating loss was maintaining his high academic achievements.

Advertisement

Photo by Oxford Science Archive/Print Collector/Getty Images

His outstanding academic performance eventually resulted in his acceptance into the University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medicine in Philadelphia. He graduated from college at the young age of 21 and began working in the field immediately after.

Advertisement

Awakening of His Interest

Dr. Doc moved his dental practice to the unruly city of Dallas, Texas, when he was 22 years old and has been there ever since. As a result of the town’s thriving oil industry, it was a town with a flourishing brass.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons / Conkling Studio

Despite having steady work and establishing himself in his new home quickly, Doc soon became bored with the routine and began spending most of his time pursuing a new interest—gambling, which had previously been a passion of his.

Advertisement

Reputation Building

Every man has a vice, a pleasure he obsesses over more than is healthy. For Doc Holliday, his was a combination of gambling and alcohol that would soon overshadow his dental practice. One night, he was gambling and drinking when the bartender accused him of cheating because he claimed Doc Holliday was winning too much.

Advertisement

Hollywood Pictures

When Doc demanded a showdown, the bartender refused to back up what he said with any money whatsoever. Disgusted by this turn of events, Doc challenged the man, and a gunfight ensued seconds later. His reputation as a mean-spirited drunk and gambler superseded any of his previous prestige as one of the town’s top physicians.

Advertisement

Getting to Know Someone Special

Mary Katherine Horony, or Big Nose Kate, was an independent, courageous woman who happened to be formidable and a superb businesswoman. She also made her living working in dance halls as a bartender and engaging in prostitution. Doc Holliday was struck by her intellect and charm when they first met.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons / Phillips Collection Photography Studio

The two were married in the carefree atmosphere of a dance hall, but it wasn’t long before lights dimmed, and the two were forced to run away from their home, their friends, and the law.

Advertisement

A New Outlaw Settlement

After accusations that Doc Holliday allegedly shot a man dead, he and his bride hastily fled one night to Dodge City, a dirty, rough town filled with prostitutes, farmers, and more outlaws of the Wild West. Their lives were about to become much more complicated.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons / Btphelps

Despite Doc’s innocence still being debated among chronologists today, the fact remains that this part of Kansas, despite having enough harmful moral decay to revert Doc to dentistry, was the safest place for the newlyweds at the time. Fear protected them for a while until one new character came into view, who wasn’t cut from the same cloth as most in the town.

Advertisement

Creating Enemies

In Dodge City, Doc Holliday met Wyatt Earp, who had earned the enmity of those he had arrested for breaking the law during his time as a temporary deputy. One night, a range of these resentful hooligans rode into Dodge and opened fire with their revolvers in Long Branch Saloon.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons / American Experience: Wyatt Earp on WXXI-TV

Doc happened to be patronizing the establishment. He dropped his playing cards just as the pianist dropped his hands from the keys and others their mugs upon hearing the deafening noise of the bullets ricocheting off the walls.

Advertisement

Bar Brawl

Wyatt rushed into the salon as soon as he heard what he’d soon discover as the bellow of Doc’s voice. Wyatt entered into the fray with his weapon drawn to defend Doc amid all the gunfire. The assailants were slightly taken aback. From then on, Wyatt and Doc formed their famed companionship.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons

Eventually, the two made their way further west, away from Dodge to Tombstone, Arizona. Wyatt and Doc picked up right where they left off: running from one adventure to the next, passing through town after dusty town, side by side.

Advertisement

The Cowboys

Wyatt chose to work as a bank security guard because his brothers were Tombstone marshals, which was a logical choice given his family’s previous experience in the field. It didn’t take long for these law enforcement officers to come across a group of part-time criminals, better known as the Cowboys.

Advertisement

Underwood Archives/Getty Images

To deal with Ike and Billy Clanton and Tom and Frank McLaury, with Billy Claiborne, Earps made a split-second decision. They pursued the gang across the Arizona Territory.

Advertisement

Craziest Shootout of All Time

After just 30 seconds of gunfire, the O.K. Corral became one of the most well-known events in American history. It all started on October 26, 1881, when Earp and Holliday retaliated against the Cowboys for threatening to murder them.

Advertisement

Robert Alexander/Getty Images

Nobody knows who fired the first shot, but there was no doubt about the number of people killed in the incident. After Virgil killed Billy Clanton, Doc Holliday shot Tom McLaury in the chest as vengeance, and Wyatt collided with Frank McLaury.

Advertisement

Arrested And Put On Trial

Things happened very quickly after 3 p.m. that autumn day. All that transpired on that tragic day happened decisively and rapidly as if it were a game. Billy and the McLaurys were dead in less than a minute after the shootout started.

Advertisement

Photo by Michael Ochs Archives/Getty Images

Soon after the fatalistic incident, Wyatt and Doc were arrested for murdering their opponents. Still, much controversy has erupted since then regarding the legal ramifications of what was supposed to be a fair fight.

Advertisement

A Friendship Forms

While the prospect of a murder trial loomed over Wyatt Earp’s head, it didn’t prevent him from spending the winter in a jail cell with Doc Holliday, who had become his closest friend and companion over the years.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons

Besides being a skilled shooter with six guns, he describes Doc as “the most brilliant gambler he’d ever met,” as well as “the nerdiest, fastest, and the deadliest guy he’d ever met.”

Advertisement

Conflicting Accounts

This scenario was a challenging one for the judges. Though there was some evidence that Wyatt and Doc were in danger from a potential threat, there were also rumors the Cowboys had no weapons as they kept their hands for their execution.

Advertisement

Hollywood Pictures

Conflicting accounts have led historians across the years disputing with little or no evidence to validate claims with certitude in either direction.

Advertisement

Who Shot First?

During the trial, witnesses gave contradictory testimony depending on whom they were supporting at the time of the questioning. Even reliable third parties could not agree on who was responsible for the attack.

Advertisement

Photo via John Kobal Foundation/Getty Images

Although there is some mildly confirmed evidence and testimony, historians today face the difficult task of excavating truth from the tombs of time to determine what happened during this famous gunfight on Fremont Street in Tombstone, Arizona.

Advertisement

And The Verdict Is...

The gunfight at the O.K. Corral was presided over by Justice of the Peace Wells Spicer, who, on November 30th, 1881, made history by ruling that Wyatt Earp and his band couldn’t be found guilty in this highly documented case.

Advertisement

YouTube / Leslie Derkovitz

They were found to be acting like law enforcement officers and protecting themselves against a convicted gunfighter who had been part of a gang attempting to rob multiple establishments within their range of influence.

Advertisement

Their Destroyed Social Images

As for the second, and perhaps more important, point of view expressed by Wells Spicer, he believed that the men should never have been deputized in the first place. It was only after a brief period of deliberation that the jury concluded that the police officers were not guilty of the charges leveled against them.

Advertisement

Hollywood Pictures

Even though they were not subjected to any legal consequences, their social standing was severely harmed due to their actions.

Advertisement

The Dentist Who Shoots Guns

Doc Holliday became well-known across the country as a swashbuckling, well-mannered dentist with a much-appreciated mustache.

Advertisement

John van Hasselt/Sygma via Getty Images

Later, he rose to prominence as a gambler and pistol slinger who also happened to be a dentist, and he created quite a stir. Doc’s admirers wished to achieve at least the same level of success as Doc in his own right, if not more.

Advertisement

A Drifter from the West

Following the completion of the public trial, Doc chose to depart Arizona. He continued to gamble for the remainder of his life even as he sailed across the Western Frontier.

Advertisement

Wikimedia Commons

Later, it turned out that Doc had given up on pursuing a dental profession and instead became an avid gambler at this stage in life. He spent some time inside jails but ultimately survived longer than many people thought he would.

Advertisement

Not So Funny

In Glenwood Springs, Colorado, Doc died of tuberculosis on November 8, 1887. He was 36 at the time of his death. Then, as he was approaching the end of his life, he took another shot of whiskey and exclaimed, “This is funny.”

Advertisement

Facebook / The Adventures of Finius the Skinniest

Although it can be difficult for historians to ascertain the truth about Western legends such as Doc Holliday, the recent rediscovery of a photographer’s photos from Tombstone provides a much clearer picture of the period in question.

Advertisement

Remembering The Wild West Through Photographs

Photographer C.S. Fly set out to capture the historical events unfolding in the growing mining town of Tombstone, which had already established itself as a legendary destination throughout the United States. It was December of 1879 when he and his wife Mary arrived in Tombstone for the first time.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons | Public Domain

They set up a makeshift photo studio in a tent and immediately began taking photographs. In June of the following year, they converted a 12-room boarding house into a studio and gallery for their work. Here are a series of pivotal photographs that expose the lifestyle and history of the American Wild West.

Advertisement

The Notorious Geronimo

There was a meeting scheduled with General George Crook of the Department of Arizona for March in 1886, and Apache chief Geronimo was putting together his preparations for it.

Advertisement

National Archives / CORBIS / Corbis / Getty Images

The military member was invited to attend the meeting, which C.S. Fly decided was significant enough to accompany him. A photograph of Geronimo presiding over a gathering of Apache leaders is displayed above.

Advertisement

Living Wages

Tombstone, a thriving mining town in the late 1800s, wasn’t always so. From here, you can see the ever-talking Tough Nut Mine, with its gated entrance in the background. Tombstone founder Ed Schieffelin controlled this mine with his brother Al and business partner Richard Gird.

Advertisement

Carleton Watkins / Wikimedia Commons | Public Domain

The Tough Nut Mine miners loved their jobs because they weren’t as dangerous as other mines. It was also one of their most accessible jobs because they didn’t have to dig very deep to find yellow ore, unlike other mines where there was practically nothing to find deep underground!

Advertisement

John Slaughter

John Slaughter is a famous figure to the many residents that live in towns scattered throughout Arizona and New Mexico.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Buyenlarge / Getty Images

Armed for protection with six-shooters, rifles, lassos, horses, and saddles, he and his men were responsible for bringing the first herd of cattle from California to Arizona Territory in 1877.

Advertisement

Apache May

For his fighting prowess, John Slaughter, the good Samaritan, was a hero to many people. He was a hero to the Apaches, too, as he protected the young Apache girl May, a victim of the Apache War, from harm.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons | Public Domain

When he was searching for a band of Apaches, he came across May, a young girl who appeared abandoned or whose parents had been killed. This may have led him to get to know May and eventually adopt her as his child.

Advertisement

Put Money On It

Because of the abundance of gold, silver, and copper mining in the area, people in historic west Arizona had a great deal of spare time to enjoy themselves.

Advertisement

Historica Graphica Collection / Heritage Images / Getty Images

In the West, they would play the Faro card game. They played it at the Orient Saloon in Bisbee, Arizona. Now and then, the residents of Tombstone would enjoy a good game of chance as well.

Advertisement

A Town That Isn't Sleepy

With around 100 people at the beginning of the twentieth century, Tombstone, Arizona, was hardly living up to its name as one of the sleepiest towns in America.

Advertisement

Buyenlarge / Getty Images

However, after just seven years of the silver mining boom, it had grown to 14,000 citizens. It saw an influx of even more diverse individuals drawn in by the promise of starting new businesses and opening up shops. During this time, many unusual occurrences happened in Tombstone, which eventually led to its worldwide fame as “the town too tough to die.”

Advertisement

Constructing a Legacy

This image depicts a photo of George Parsons, Tombstone’s most prominent historian. As the city quickly rose to fame for its Wild West flair, so too did Parsons’ passion for writing about truthfully documenting its history.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons

While maintaining his life as a practicing lawyer, he wrote about the escapades of the outlaws who passed through the city and the townspeople who lived there. Later in life, he would leave his career behind to become a banker and record Tombstone’s legacy throughout his writings.

Advertisement

Geronimo and His Tribe

Geronimo developed an interest in photography due to his meeting with Crook and C.S. Fly in the following months.

Advertisement

API / Gamma-Rapho / Getty Images

Fly was commissioned to take this photograph of Geronimo and his fellow tribesmen in the field, which he did. Tsisnah, Geronimo’s son, stands by his side as he mounts his horse for the first time in this photograph.

Advertisement

The Tombstone Mines

Tombstone made most of its money in the 19th century from transporting ore from mines to nearby stamp mills. Stamp mills were heavy machines that crush rocks into a fine powder, which was used to separate gold and silver from rock.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Wikimedia Commons

As C.S. Fly documented, these mules moved ore from the mining area into the mills.

Advertisement

Samantha Fallon

Samantha Fallon is pictured at the San Jose House Hostel and Millinery Shop in Tombstone, Arizona.

Advertisement

u/Paul-Belgium / Reddit

Samantha and Ed Schieffelin, the creator of Tombstone, were in a relationship before they married other people.

Advertisement

Surrender by Geronimo

When a troop of Apache warriors under the command of their brave leader Geronimo emerged from the woods, CS Fly was there to witness the event.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Library of Congress / Corbis / VCG / Getty Images

This photograph was taken on the 27th of March, 1886, in the Mexican highlands of the Sierra Madre, just minutes before Geronimo surrendered to General Crook. The event took place in the Mexican highlands of the Sierra Madre.

Advertisement

O.K. Corral Shootout And Boot Hill Cemetery

As you know, one of the most significant events in Wild West history occurred on October 26th, 1881 – it was the day that the Clanton Gang was subdued after a long and challenging gunfight with Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and those they fought alongside.

Advertisement

Arizona State Library, Archives and Public Records. History and Archives Division.

Tom McLaury, Frank McLaury, and Billy Clanton wouldn’t stand a chance against their adversaries! These ruthless bandits are all buried in Tombstone’s Boot Hill Cemetery, where visitors pay their respects.

Advertisement

Potential Peace in the West

After Geronimo’s surrender, Apache leader Naiche accompanied troops from General Crook’s group to a rendezvous with the Mexican military and various Apache bands, who were also there to finalize an agreement.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Library of Congress / Corbis / VCG / Getty Images

As unusual as it was for soldiers from opposing armies and potentially lethal opponents to be in the same place at once, both parties put aside their personal feelings about each other for the greater good of an agreement that would ensure peace for everyone involved.

Advertisement

The Grand Hotel

It is possible to see the Grand Hotel in the background of this scene. When it comes to lodging options in Tombstone, few compare to the Grand Hotel, which is widely considered the most opulent in the entire state.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Arizona Historical Society / Wikimedia Commons

As a result of the great fire of 1882, C.S. Fly demonstrated that he was a visionary by developing one of the state’s first resorts, which is still in operation today.

Advertisement

A Brand-New Place to Call Home

It is possible to witness many Apache children here in this area. “Jimmy” McKinn is a boy kidnapped by Apache warriors in Silver City, New Mexico, and taken far away. Luckily, he became quickly attached to his new life amongst these people.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / Library of Congress

Even though he was held against his will, he eventually chose not to return with the soldiers, instead preferring his new way of living, despite initial resistance.

Advertisement

The Historical Shootout Site

In this historical photo from the Wild West, we see the remains of the O.K. Corral, the site of one of America’s iconic historical shootouts.

Advertisement

John van Hasselt / Sygma / Getty Images

This infamous battle may have only last thirty seconds, but within that timeframe, thirty shots were fired and the conflict became ended three lives.

Advertisement

Preparation is the Key to Success

As Geronimo was surrounded and on the verge of surrendering in the final days of his surrender proceedings, it was unclear what kind of resistance the Apache chief would mount against the United States Army.

Advertisement

C.S. Fly / The New-York Historical Society / Getty Images

Because scouts like Lieutenant Maus were on standby, they were prepared to meet any challenges they might encounter while tracking down and invading Apache territory. Fortunately, this did not become a problem.

Advertisement

Taking Pride in Their Work

Upon Geronimo’s request, this picture was taken to remember the respected Apache chief at his most famous peak in life.

Advertisement

MPI / Getty Images

“Geronimo” is perhaps one of the few names that strike fear into the hearts of white settlers and troops alike even today due to his legendary part in Wild West history, where he became renowned for his military tactics, which attracted many and fueled fear in others.

Advertisement

Raging Inferno

Although his widow Mary carried on the couple’s photography feats after her husband, C.S. Flyer, passed away in 1901, the family business was unfortunately burned down in 1915 by a fire that came as a total surprise to everyone who had followed their work for so many years.

Advertisement

Mary Fly / Wikimedia Commons

This photograph of the studio’s ashes and smoke is said to be taken by Mary as perhaps one final tribute to their life’s beloved art before its entire history was washed away by flames.

Advertisement